Insights · Directional Clarity · Field Notes

The Gut Feeling That Tells You When You're Off Your Values

That confidence in your gut when something is right is a real neurological process called interoception, your brain sensing the internal state of your body. In leadership it is the difference between reacting to noise and responding with conviction. Here is how to read it, and a simple exercise to aim it. Adapted from the Neuvero video Interoception.

Prefer to watch? Overwhelmed? It Might Be a Values Problem on the Neuvero YouTube channel.

Most leaders I work with are overwhelmed, either by the sheer demand on their time or by the number of good opportunities in front of them, or they are worn down by the politics and paper cuts of daily leadership. Underneath all three is the same quiet problem: too much of our time and energy goes to things that are not actually aligned with what matters most to us.

So let me ask the harder question. What if you were genuinely clear on what was most important to you? Not the mission statement version, but the one or two things that will still matter when you finish this trip around the sun. Most of the time we already know. When you say it out loud, you tend to feel a surprising confidence in your gut that it is right.

That gut feeling is not just a figure of speech. It is a real neurological process called interoception.

What your gut is actually doing

Interoception is your brain's ability to sense the internal state of your body: your heart rate, your breath, the tightening in your chest when something feels off, the settling in your shoulders when something feels right. There is a whole neural system devoted to reading these internal signals, and it feeds directly into how you judge and decide. This is the mechanism behind what researchers call somatic markers, the bodily signals that tag an option as good or bad a beat before you can explain why. Your body often reaches the verdict before your conscious mind can find the words.

In leadership, that internal sense is the difference between reacting to noise and responding with conviction. When you are truly in alignment with what matters, your body knows it before your mind catches up. When you are off track, the body knows that too, and it usually tells you well before the quarter's results do. The problem is not that the signal is missing. The problem is that most of us are too busy, too stressed, and too far up in our heads to feel it.

Aiming the compass

A compass is only useful if you read it, so here is a way to make the signal legible. It takes about two minutes and a scrap of paper.

Draw a bullseye. The center represents living fully aligned with your most important values. The outer ring represents being completely off track. Now mark an X for how close to the center you actually are in each of four areas of your life.

First, work. Are you leading with the impact you actually intended, or just clearing the queue? Second, relationships. Are you present for the people who genuinely matter to you, or present in body only? Third, leisure and fun. Are you truly recharging, or just scrolling until it is time to work again? Fourth, health and self-care. Are you maintaining the instrument that does all of the work, or running it into the ground and hoping?

Do not overthink the marks. The point is not a precise score. The point is to give your interoceptive sense a place to land, so the vague unease of being off track becomes something specific you can see. Most people find that one ring is startlingly far from the center, and that it is the one they have been quietly avoiding.

Why this is not a feel-good exercise

It would be easy to file all of this under wellness and move on. That would be a mistake. Your values are not a soft indulgence layered on top of the real work. They are the driving force that lets you and your organization make good decisions, move quickly, and serve your customers better. A leader who is clear on what matters decides faster, because most of the hard calls stop being genuinely hard once you know what you are optimizing for. A leader who has lost that clarity ends up relitigating the same decision over and over, because there is no fixed point to measure it against.

There is a compounding effect, too. When you are aligned, your interoceptive signal gets easier to read, because you are no longer flooding it with the stress of doing work that quietly violates what you care about. When you are chronically misaligned, the signal gets buried under noise, and you start making more of your decisions from that reactive, off-center place. Clarity is not just pleasant. It is upstream of your judgment.

So this week, before the next big decision lands, try the two-minute version. Draw the bullseye, mark the four rings honestly, and notice which one your gut has been trying to tell you about. What is the one area furthest from the center, and what is the smallest move that would pull it back toward what matters most?

References

  • Craig, A. D. (2002). How do you feel? Interoception: the sense of the physiological condition of the body. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 3(8), 655-666. doi:10.1038/nrn894
  • Bechara, A., & Damasio, A. R. (2005). The somatic marker hypothesis: A neural theory of economic decision. Games and Economic Behavior, 52(2), 336-372. doi:10.1016/j.geb.2004.06.010
  • Wilson, K. G., Sandoz, E. K., Kitchens, J., & Roberts, M. (2010). The Valued Living Questionnaire. The Psychological Record, 60(2), 249-272. doi:10.1007/bf03395706

Adapted from the Neuvero video Interoception. Related: Acceptance and Commitment: Two Words That Reframe How You Lead (turning values into committed action) and The Human Harness, on tuning your own operating system.

Frequently asked questions

What is a quick values alignment exercise for busy leaders?

Draw a bullseye on a scrap of paper, where the center means living fully aligned with your most important values and the outer ring means completely off track. Mark an X for how close to the center you actually are in four areas: work, relationships, leisure and fun, and health and self-care. It takes about two minutes, and the point is not a precise score but giving your gut sense a place to land, so vague unease becomes something specific you can see. Most people find one ring is startlingly far out, and it is usually the one they have been quietly avoiding.

What is interoception and why does it matter for leaders?

Interoception is your brain's ability to sense the internal state of your body: your heart rate, your breath, the tightening in your chest when something feels off, the settling in your shoulders when something feels right. It matters because those bodily signals, what researchers call somatic markers, tag an option as good or bad a beat before you can explain why, so your body often reaches a verdict before your conscious mind finds the words. For a leader that internal sense is the difference between reacting to noise and responding with conviction.

What are the physical signs you are out of alignment with your values?

Your body tends to register it before your mind does, often as a tightening in your chest or a low, persistent unease when something feels off. When you are aligned there is more of a settling, a steadiness in your shoulders and gut. The tricky part is that being too busy, too stressed, and too far up in your head can bury the signal, which is exactly why slowing down to read it is worth the two minutes.

If your calendar has drifted away from what matters most

Executive coaching at Neuvero works on exactly this: reconnecting how you spend your days with the values that actually drive you, so decisions get clearer and faster. One-to-one, video, worldwide.

Explore Executive Coaching

Or start with a conversation: book an intro call. Leading a team, not just yourself? Try the self-paced Team Velocity Accelerator.